The Smartest Kids in the World are created by the smartest (and bravest) education policy makers.

Gregg Glover Harvard School of Education

This week’s edition of The Economist contains a review and discussion of Amanda Ripley’s “The Smartest Kids in the World: And How They Got That Way.”  The book readdresses some of theAmanda Ripley woes in the US education system where the notion of ‘teaching to the test’ has become the norm and ‘critical thinking’  has been forgotten. As usual, Finland and several Asian countries do very well. Poland also gets good marks for the improvements in its education system. European who have been panicking about the supposed army of Polish plumbers ready to invade Britain, France and Germany should be warned. Soon they may be joined by battalions of  highly skilled accountants, lawyers and doctors.

Tony Wagner has championed the critical thinking approach for five years

Tony Wagner has championed the critical thinking approach for five years

Many of Ms. Ripley’s idea have already been set down by Tony Wagner who has been championing the ‘critical thinking approach’ for the past five years. Mr. Wagner will be glad to have a new ally. Ms. Ripley makes two very interesting points in her discussion on the book.


Lots of technology does not always mean good teaching 

The first is that lots of technology can help teaching but only if used intelligently. Indeed, some of the best teaching she saw occurred in some of the poorest environments. In contrast Ms. Ripley talks about wonderfully equipped classrooms in the US being inhabited by some of the most bored students. Dire lessons being taught in high tech rooms.  This technology obsession has got to the point where certain schools across the world are now even imposing the use of iPads in class even though any teaching will tell you just what a distraction they are.

None of this should not come as a surprise to anyone that really enjoys teaching. Most good professors and teachers that I know have a very low tech style. Wasn’t Socrates rather a good pedagogue despite his lack of high tech equipment? And if I think back to the good teachers I remember from my school and university days, they had a similar style. In fact, what they did was very simple. They asked us challenging questions and then made us interact to find answers and solutions. Exactly the same type of challenges that millions of people face up to every day in their work.

For sure, having technology in the classroom is a great aid. It is quite wonderful that thanks to “You Tube” in a middle of a discussion on strategy I can bring Michael Porter or even the late Steve Jobs into the class with me. Such video clips are a lively way to break up the lessons and to keep students’ attention. It also gives them the opportunity to make judgements for themselves. Having,Cover anyone using videos to illustrate certain points will know that students tend to switch off after a few minutes. This doesn’t make them bad students; it makes them human. They switch back on again when they are asked for their opinion and required to engage once more with their colleagues. Learning, as Jean Lave and Etienne Wenger have consistently pointed out, is a social interaction.

Economic incentives to attract the best people to teaching 

Ms. Ripley also points out top performing countries such as Finland, South Korea, Japan and Singapore also introduced some basic economics into the process of teaching training.  The teaching training colleges were closed down so that future teachers could be taught in the elite universities. In Finland 8 out of 8 universities that teach teachers are deemed to be ‘highly selective’ and requires applicants to be in the top 10% of their high school cohort. (In the USA, only 1 in 20 colleges is selective. So, teachers suddenly have a high status.)  These countries then accompanied this policy by financial incentives to encourage the best students to go into teaching.

Investing in people in business and in education 

mainIn his book about his time at General Electric,  Jack Welch stated that his first instinct was always to attract and keep the best people. The same idea that works so well in business should be applied to education. Perhaps education policy makers should begin to take note. Invest in people, not in objects. Use financial incentives and competition to bring the best talent into teaching and the results will follow. Of course, on the flip side this would mean that teachers and professors would have to accept positions that gives fewer guarantees than they do today. If they are confident in their abilities to enhance learning in a classroom, this should not be a problem. Real market forces within the education system. It has worked in countries as different as Finland and South Korea, so it should work anywhere else.


See also:

French Management Schools: Stop apologizing!

Studying in FranceOver the past 20 years, management schools in France have led the way in providing young internationally minded graduates fit to work in modern business. They should recognize this and stop apologizing for what they have achieved.

iFail….the Sint-Jozef business school, Belgium imposes the purchase of an iPad

The Sint-Jozef business school in Belgium has made the purchase of an iPad compulsory for all its students. This has provoked the ire of a certain number of parents who complain about the extra cost. What few people have mentioned is that the academic performance of the students will almost certainly diminish once they have an iPad. This often happens when the technology begins to dictate academic decisions.

AACSB Annual Meeting (ICAM 2013): Learning, Leading, and Teaching in the 21st Century (Tony Wagner, Technology & Entrepreneurship Center at Harvard)

Tony Wagner coverAt the AACSB ICAM 2013 Conference, Tony Wagner, Innovation Education Fellow at Technology & Entrepreneurship Center at Harvard, talked about the learning gaps that are affecting students across the world, and gave some strategies for how to prepare them for the new global knowledge society.

A good teacher can inspire hope, ignite the imagination, and instill a love of learning.

Crazy Train to Tinky Town: “The very first morning, I slunk into her class and claimed one of the desks at the rear whilst awaiting the hellion herself. As we all made to stand she gestured for us to remain seated before what I came to discover was her usual soft-spoken greeting of “Good Morning Ladies”.


Filed under Business Schools, Education, Europe, Exchange study programs, Higher Education, Management, Strategy, USA

3 responses to “The Smartest Kids in the World are created by the smartest (and bravest) education policy makers.

  1. This was all very interesting, Mark! Thanks for sharing with us! 🙂

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s